Archive for May, 2011
DUI Defense Lawyer Strategies – Part 1
May 28th, 2011 | 
Author: Contact a local lawyer now for a FREE consultation!
(800)384-5297
(800)384-5297
A video of excerpts from California DUI attorney Lawrence Taylor’s keynote lecture at the North Carolina Trial Lawyer Academy to over 100 lawyers. Part 1 www.duicentral.com
Posted in 
What To Do When The Police Break The Law: Motions In A Dui Case
Free Online Articles Directory
Why Submit Articles?
Top Authors
Top Articles
FAQ
ABAnswers
0 && $.browser.msie ) {
var ie_version = parseInt($.browser.version);
if(ie_version Login
Register
Hello
My Home
Sign Out
Email
Password
Remember me?
Lost Password?
Home Page > Law > Criminal > What To Do When The Police Break The Law: Motions In A Dui Case
Categories
AdvertisingArts & EntertainmentAutomotiveBeautyBusinessCareersComputersEducationFinanceFood and BeverageHealthHobbiesHome and FamilyHome ImprovementInternetLawMarketingNews and SocietyRelationshipsSelf ImprovementShoppingSpiritualitySports and FitnessTechnologyTravelWriting
]]>
What To Do When The Police Break The Law: Motions In A Dui Case
By: tim
Posted: Feb 24, 2009
Views: 263
When a defendant or his attorney files a motion to suppress evidence he is asking the judge to rule that evidence is inadmissible because it has been obtained illegally. If evidence is inadmissible then it cannot come in at a Defendant’s trial. If incriminating evidence is kept out of a defendant’s trial, then the prosecution’s case may be seriously weakened or destroyed.
There are a number of reasons why evidence may be illegally obtained and therefore inadmissible. A good DUI lawyer in San Diego will review your case to determine whether the possible reasons for evidence to be inadmissible are present in your case. For example, if a police officer arrests a defendant but does not read the defendant his Miranda rights then any statements made by the defendant after his arrest and before the reading of his Miranda rights may be inadmissible.
In DUI criminal cases in San Diego the most damaging pieces of evidence are usually the results of breath or blood tests as well as a defendant’s performance on field sobriety tests. So, excluding a defendant’s post-arrest statements isn’t usually going to seriously weaken the prosecution’s case.
Another reason why excluding post-arrest statements may not put a big dent in the prosecutions case is that appellate courts have ruled that the initial contact between a police officer and a driver subjected to a DUI stop is not an arrest. Defendants generally make their most damaging statements early on in their contact with the police; for example, telling an officer how much they had to drink.
]]>
Because defendant’s generally make the most damaging statements early on, during the ‘investigation’ rather than the ‘arrest’ phase of the DUI stop, and because the most damaging evidence is usually the blood or breath tests, not the defendants’ statements, excluding evidence based on a failure to advise a defendant of his Miranda rights is rarely the key to winning a DUI case in San Diego.
But there is still good reason to file a motion to suppress in the right case; a motion to suppress in a DUI case can be a useful tool when a defendant argues that he was stopped or arrested illegally, as opposed to arguing that he made post-arrest statements without a Miranda warning. For example, if a police officer observes that an eventual defendant’s car wheels touch a lane line and observes no other irregularities in the defendant’s driving, then the police officer might not have a legal basis to stop the defendant. If the officer nonetheless stops the defendant, and the officer’s investigation leads the officer to suspect that the defendant is driving under the influence, then the defendant may argue to the judge that the initial stop was illegal.
If the defendant or his attorney can persuade the judge that the initial stop was illegal, then the judge might rule that all evidence obtained after the illegal stop — i.e., the result of a Blood Test, Breath Test or a Field Sobriety Test — is inadmissible in trial.
A motion to suppress can also be valuable because it offers an opportunity to a DUI lawyer to cross-examine a police officer in court in order to find out what the officer’s testimony will be at trial.
Another motion that may be filed is called a Pitchess motion. If a defendant wins a Pitchess motion then the judge will order the Police Department to give the defendant or his lawyer the contact information for other citizens who have filed complaints against the defendant’s arresting officers for dishonesty or use of excessive force. As discussed above, the case may arise where an officer writes in his police report that a defendant swerved across a lane line, and the defendant knows that his wheels just touched the lane line. In that kind of case it might be useful for a defendant to file a Pitchess motion in order to locate witnesses who might call the police officer’s credibility into question by testifying that the police officer has been dishonest in other cases.
To cause the court to hear a motion to suppress, a DUI attorney prepares a legal document that includes argument to persuade the judge to decide the motion in the defendant’s favor, and makes four copies of the document. The attorney goes to the San Diego courthouse to provide the documents to a court clerk, and asks the clerk to set a date when the motion may be heard in court, in front of a judge. The clerk keeps two copies for the court, and returns two copies to the attorney with the court’s official stamp. The attorney then takes the two stamped copies to the office of the prosecutor (the San Diego City Attorney or the San Diego District Attorney). The prosecutor’s office keeps one copy, and provides the attorney with a stamped copy. The attorney then has a copy of the motion with confirmation from the court that the motion has been filed and a date has been set, as well as confirmation from the prosecutor’s office that he has provided the prosecutor with a copy of the motion.
tim – About the Author:
For more information about DUI, visit DrunkDrivingSD.com — San Diego DUI Lawyer
]]>
Increase your traffic today just by submitting articles with us, click here to get started.
Liked this article? Click here to publish it on your website or blog, it’s free and easy!
Rate this Article
vote(s)
0 vote(s)
0) {
ch_selected = Math.floor(Math.random()*ch_queries.length);
if(ch_selected == ch_queries.length) ch_selected–;
ch_query = ch_queries[ch_selected];
}
}catch(e){
ch_query = document.title;
}
]]>
Article Tags:
dui law, dui lawyer, dui lawyers in san diego, san diego dui, san diego dui lawyers, san diego dui lawyer, san diego dui attorney, san diego dui attorneys, drunkdriving, drunk driving sd, dui san diego, dui specialist, drunk driving california
Responsibility of a Criminal Defence Lawyer
A criminal defence lawyer can prove very useful in avoiding the criminal record. A criminal lawyer look after the cases like impaired driving, drug charges, assault, theft, murder and so on.
By: criminallaw
Locate Someones Identity With Georgia Police Records
If you are one to take precedence to safety most ostensibly you are going to resort to file-rummaging steps just to find out about a person before seriously regarding that someone. To get Georgia Police Records is imperative on your quest to fully reveal the person you are having connections with.
By: Elaine Jeans
Fast Information With Texas Police Records
In Texas the Crime Records Service of the DPS secures and files records of pertinent information of people arrested, charged, or convicted of a criminal act regardless of whether the conviction was probated. Usage of such data files is also permitted in accordance to Texas statute.
By: Elaine Jeans
Where To Buy Reverse Phone Lookup Online
Can’t identify a phone number that you’ve discovered in your pants pocket, wallet, or somewhere else? Perhaps you have experienced talking hurriedly to a friend, co-worker, customer, or manager.
By: Elaine Jeans
How To Gather Facts And Information About Missouri Background Check
At an instance when you feel getting a Missouri Background Check is peace of mind, few things are nonetheless needed to be followed and taken note of. Good news is anybody may obtain a criminal history records screen on any individual; in fact the State Central Repository for these records may provide “open records” that have been reported to the Archive.
By: Elaine Jeans
Comments on this article [0]
Add new Comment
Related Videos
Dangers Of Alcoholism And Driving Intoxicated
Ask a question
Ask our experts your Criminal related questions here…
200 Characters left
Related Questions
I heard that an Employer told someone they could not use there personl car on there 15 minute break because they are being payed for it. Is it breaking the law for the employer to have such polices
How many dui cases are dismissed?
How many breath tests are required in a dui case
]]>
Need Help?
Contact Us
FAQ
Submit Articles
Editorial Guidelines
Blog
Site Links
Recent Articles
Top Authors
Top Articles
Find Articles
Site Map
Mobile Version
Webmasters
RSS Builder
RSS
Link to Us
Business Info
Advertising
Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy | User published content is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Copyright (c) 2005-2011 Free Articles by ArticlesBase.com, All rights reserved.
Originally published here.
Calif. lawmaker seeks to regulate DUI checkpoints
SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — A week after Nora Ramos gave birth by Caesarean section, she found herself walking five miles home with her husband and four children.
Published May 26, 2011.
Read more: Tahoe Daily Tribune